Labour faced a significant defeat in Gorton and Denton, as the Green Party claimed victory in what was considered one of Labour’s safest seats. The dramatic decline in Labour’s vote share by 25% came as a surprise to activists who had been actively campaigning in Greater Manchester. The party’s third-place finish, behind Reform UK, added to the blow. Local plumber Hannah Spencer’s success as the first Green candidate to win a by-election was celebrated by the Greens, who had not initially prioritized the Greater Manchester seat.

Despite disappointment, Keir Starmer conveyed determination to continue the fight, emphasizing the need for change that voters are eager to see. Government sources highlighted the importance of focusing on the progressive manifesto and addressing the cost of living concerns to appeal to mainstream Britain. Some Labour MPs expressed frustration, suggesting that a different candidate, like Andy Burnham, could have secured victory in the by-election. However, the majority of Labour MPs have remained silent on the issue, looking ahead to the upcoming elections in May as a crucial test for Starmer’s leadership.